Discussion: View Thread

Issues between IARP and ICHCC

  • 1.  Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-20-2022 12:30

    Good afternoon, Colleagues

    I do not know how many of our CLCPs are on this forum and also on the ICHCC Collaborative Group email distribution / listserv, so I thought it prudent to share. On 08/12/22, I posted an email, followed by a second one on 08/13/22, to the ICHCC Collaborative Group asking questions regarding:

    1. Why ICHCC did not provide CEUs for our May 2022 Summit
    2. Why I had heard that ICHCC was not going to provide CEUs for our October 2022 Symposium and Conference
    3. How it was that the AAACEU's continuing education, which is the primary way CLCPs can in fact get their hours for recertification, is being taught by an ICHCC Commissioner 
    3. Why CLCPs have not had an update on the goal to get our certification body ICHCC accredited/approved for accreditation by the ANSI [American National Standards Institute] (now now called ANAB)

    The emails I sent did upset two CLCPs on the ICHCC Collaborative Group listserv, who felt this discussion was not appropriate on the public forum. Several other CLCPs added to the discussion with similar concerns and questions. At least ten other CLCPs emailed or called me privately, who supported my posts, but did not intend to post publicly about their opinions for whatever reason. 

    To Kathleen May's credit, she called me directly on Sunday to try and explain some of the issues from their perspective and to update me on the ANSI situation. I very much appreciated having the opportunity to air my concerns verbally with Mrs. May, although in the end, i still do not have many answers. She did share that the ICHCC has had many discussions with IARP Leadership [Not IALCP Leadership] to try and work out the issues at hand [although I cannot articulate what exactly the issues are] but that she feels the negotiations are going nowhere at the moment, and she is not hopeful that ICHCC will be approving educational content in the immediate future.  She called out some of our leaders by name, whom I will not share here publicly, but based on the information I was given, I feel that maybe IARP leadership / management is not being completely transparent on what the issues are. While I do not believe it is entirely our organization's fault by any means, there does appear to have been some missteps along the way that have made this situation worse and potentially not repairable. 

     

    There was a follow up email to the ICHCC Collaborative Group from IARP leadership this last week, after seeing the Friday through Sunday posts. That email stated that the conference documentation for getting approved for CEUs by all of the certifying agencies, is in progress, and not submitted yet, so we do not know what will and will not be approved quite yet. I completely understand that fact, but based on what I have been told by ICHCC, they will not be providing us CEUS for the CLCP, regardless of the quality content of the presentations. This is no longer about if our educational content meets the standards. This is way bigger than that.  I think it is important for our CLCPs to know this now, before they start spending money on travel arrangements or turning down work because they will be out of the office for most of a week.  

    Let me be clear, I will be at the Symposium, and I am in no way discouraging any of our members to not to go the October event. I for one, find greater value in the networking with my colleagues and learning new information, then my CEUs / CLCP provide to me on paper. I also think we need to come together to have face to face meetings about these current challenges. 

    What upsets me is that I feel very in the dark as to what has been going on behind the scenes between the two organizations and how there has not been any transparency provided to us, the members, by IARP or ICHCC .  IARP is an organization that WE pay for. WE volunteer for. WE advocate for. Their job is to support US. They work for US.  There have been lawsuits filed against a couple of our IALCP members in the past year that have been kept under wraps. No one is talking about it [those who were sued cannot talk about it openly].  IARP knew of the lawsuits, they have not supported those members, even when one suit included a volunteer leader who should have been protected from these types of claims.

    Mrs. May actually asked me if I could somehow help to resolve the problems that lay before us. I would love to be involved in that, but I cannot help to resolve problems that I do not understand. I am told by Mrs. May that there are years of paper trails that document the issues at hand. There are organizational problems and there are exchanges which have become very personal. Neither are going to be resolved easily, if at all.  

    I implore IARP and ICHCC leadership to provide our members the information we need to make our own best decisions. While again, I reiterate that I will be at the Symposium, if for no other reason, to have face to face discussions with each other and those involved, but also because these are the professional decisions that I am facing and I think all of you are as well:

    1. Do I attend future conferences for the love of networking and education, if they do not provide me what I need to stay certified?
    2. Do I even keep my CLCP designation in the future and does it really even have any value any longer?
    3. Do I continue my membership in an organization that may not actually support me if I need them?
    4. Do I volunteer to work for an organization that may not support me if I need them?

     I encourage everybody to continue the conversation and think about what we, as an industry of life care planners, should be doing at this point to make a difference. We are already a splintered community in many ways and this is making it much worse.

     



    ------------------------------
    Tracy Albee
    tracy@medilegalinc.com
    TRACY, CA & HENDERSON, NV
    United States
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-20-2022 13:40
    Thank you for the enlightening email. Who is in charge of submitting Ceu applications for Iarp?  It should be a matter of completing forms and providing the documentation needed. I think one of Iarps primary responsibilities to members is to provide quality education that is approved for continuing education purposes. 

    Sent from my iPhone





  • 3.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-21-2022 13:29

    Hi Maria,

     

    Just to be clear, this is not about the content of our education or it not meeting the standards. This is politics.

     

    Tracy Albee, RN LNCC CLCP FIALCP

    MediLegal, A Professional Nursing Corp

    1852 West 11th Street, #333

    Tracy, CA  95376

    209-833-7251

    tracy@medilegalinc.com

     

    Offices in Tracy, CA and Las Vegas, NV

     

    2023 Vacation Alert: I will be away from approximately June 5 thorugh July 5, 2023 and will be be unable to take accept new work with trials on calendar during that timeframe.

     

    The information contained in this message may be privileged, confidential and protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify your representative immediately and delete this message from your computer. Thank you.

     






  • 4.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-22-2022 12:33

    Good afternoon, All,

     

    Tracy, thanks for coming forward to ask about & discuss this matter.

     

    In an attempt to keep up, I requested to join the ICHCC Collaborative Group but have not yet been granted access. Nevertheless, I have been hearing about the concerns expressed below since (at least) the 2022 Summit did not provide CLCP CEUs approved by ICHCC. I note that some in the ICHCC online group felt the issues raised by Tracy below were not appropriate for public discussion. I don't understand that & wonder how we CLCPs & IARP members are supposed to figure out what is going on.

     

    For what reason did Ms. May tell Tracy that "...she is not hopeful that ICHCC will be approving educational content in the immediate future?" This is despite the fact the CEU applications have reportedly not yet been filed. That does not make sense.

     

    I am also willing to work with Tracy on resolution of the issues of concern, as soon as I understand what those issues are. It is absurd that a professional association and a professional certification body are squabbling at the expense of the individual professionals who pay for their services.

     

    On a side note, I just spent two years, along with many other diligent life care planners, working on a revision of the LCP Standards. The people involved were serious, committed, and working on doing the right thing for the subspecialty practice of life care planning. The process of Standards revision (my 2nd time being involved) illustrated for me how many people's different opinions can be heard, even if everyone does not "get their way." I mention this in order to demonstrate the simple fact that professional people know how to behave professionally.

     

    For what reason have OUR issues (mentioned by Tracy below) gotten mixed up in such a huge breakdown in communication?

     

    I also implore both IARP and ICHCC to be open & let us know what is going on & how they plan to fix it.

     

    PattyC

    Patricia A. Costantini,

    RN, MEd, LPC, CRC, CCM, CLCP, LNCC, ABVE/D, CNLCP

    A button with "Hear my name" text for name playback in email signature

    Costantini Rehab, Inc.

    412-939-3424  (Preferred)

    fax 412-939-3427

    cell 412-849-1619

     

     






  • 5.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-22-2022 14:24

    Tracy:  Thank you for bringing up these valid concerns felt by many.   These past few years have been particularly difficult for leadership and the IARP members.  We have dealt with a pandemic, narrowly avoiding a $200,000 penalty for cancelling the 2020 conference, which required legal intervention, decisions to have live conferences and symposiums again versus yet another Zoom conference or hybrid, and a host of other matters.  We have served on the board over the past 5 years and served on numerous other committees prior to that time.  We are excited to have a new vibrant group of leaders who care deeply about IARP and our members. 


    The problems you mention below are on the forefront of the work the Board is doing.  Unfortunately, you are correct; there was a lawsuit involving 2 life care planning members by Dr. May and we were countersued as an organization.  We were directed by our attorneys on what we could or could not communicate about the legal proceedings.  We have had to work upon advice of our attorneys after the insurance company denied the claim, and were advised to  inform our members that we are working diligently to resolve the matter and working on the advice of our legal counsel.  As individual members have reached out to the board, that information has been provided.  This case has recently resolved and once everything is finalized, we hope to provide transparency and information to the membership.  We did support our members who were sued to the extent that we were able, and given our legal advice.  We certainly did everything in our power to help resolve the issue, at a cost of well over $35,000 in associated costs.


    Any member can privately contact a Board member with questions and many have. We realize you have served the organization and your heart is in seeing IARP thrive so that we all as a result can excel in our practices. There is a great deal of misinformation and confusion among the membership. 

    Although we realize something is needed this minute, and we will reach out to you to talk about it, there is always the business meeting at the conference, which is a great time to meet the board and ask questions. I would encourage all to attend.   In addition,  the last issue of the journal will provide section and overall IARP updates. It was a great suggestion by our editors last year and a good place to document our successes and goals. There will also be legal expenses, etc. that have been incurred, etc. 


    There has been communication with Mrs. May and Susan Riddick-Grisham and the new IALCP chairs in an effort to heal the organization and obtain CEUs and all work together. This effort continues. From the Board's perspective, the initial discussions were thought to have been positive but it appears that you have  heard a different opinion.  The IARP board will continue to work with the IALCP section, our valued LCP membership, and of course, ICHCC to resolve our differences and move forward in a positive manner.


    We have been diligently working to resolve these matters under the guidance of legal counsel and will continue to wholeheartedly support our organization. Many on the IARP Board are Life Care Planners and want to continue to do the work that we love and are passionate about, without having to worry about getting our continuing education units. We have been trying to resolve matters that are deep and personal but continue to have hope that we shall move forward as we can. Please know there has been communication throughout this matter in order to discuss the relationship between an accrediting body and IARP, just as we do with CRCC, CDMS, ABVE, etc.  We will keep on and hope that when matters are completely resolved, which will take time, we can continue to become the leading international rehabilitation professional association. 


    Julie Sawyer-Little, Director of Education

    Anne Savage Veh, IARP President

    Dana Beining, IARP President Elect

    Michelle McBroom Weiss, Secretary

    Gil Spruance, Treasurer

    Evie Cowitz, Council of Chapter Presidents

     










  • 6.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-22-2022 15:13
    Julie-
    I want to correct one of your statements. I have not had any conversations with Mrs. May or Dr. May. 
    Susan
    Susan Riddick-Grisham
    sgrisham@grishamzaras.com
    The Care Planner Network
    800-252-1094
    Cell 804-310-5239

       






  • 7.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-22-2022 16:18
    Thanks for the correction Susan.  Julie





  • 8.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-22-2022 18:28
    Julie, Anne, Dana, et al:

    Thanks for bringing some light on these very serious issues that threaten the entire practice of life care planning and all IARP and IALCP members, certified or not; however, there seems to be more that could be shared, unless IARP counsel's "gag order" prevents it.  I think what you posted as an explanation is an important start but only scratches the surface.  I hope that more of the history of this conflict can come to light and be shared. I believe it is imperative that this occur.

    This conflict and the underlying case (that is a matter of public record in US District Court records, including a ruling) is important to read and understand.  I am confident that this by no means gives the complete story of the present conflict between ICHCC and IARP, so I urge both IARP and ICHCC to be more transparent.

    I sit in a unique position.  I am a past-president of IARP (2005-2007) and it was during my term that the IALCP came into the IARP fold as a special interest section.  This was perhaps one of my greatest accomplishments as IARP president and my close work with the founder of the IALCP, Patti McCollum, to make this happen is still a source of great pride to me, especially as life care planning as an area of practice has grown.  The practice continues to thrive, but. sadly, there are now unnecessary competing factions for the perceived leadership of  the life care planning community.  The only common thread, it seems, that ties us together is the desire to promote quality life care planning practice; however, as long as there continues to be conflict between nurse and non-nurse life care planners as well as the multiple certifying bodies, these problems will continue and I am not hopeful that everyone can play nice in the sandbox due to their own self-interests.

    I am also a former commissioner of life care planning for the ICHCC.  I decided to resign from that role a number of years ago for personal reasons.

    I remind everyone of the "Consensus and Majority Statements Derived from Life Care Planning Summits Held in 2000, 2002, 2004, 2006, 2008, 2010, 2012 and 2015," specifically Consensus Statement #25 as published in the Journal of Life Care Planning 13(4) 2015: The Life Care Planning certifying body shall not be proprietary.    

    The authors recognized the problem that could exist by having the body that certified life care planners over seven years ago be a for-profit as opposed to a non-profit entity.  I suspect that this may be a complicating factor in resolving the ongoing issues that exist today.   I know of no other certifying body or licensing entity that is privately owned. 

    I am not in IARP leadership at the present time.  As a past-president, I am a Life Member of IARP.  While I continue to be a CLCP, the issues now being discussed will affect whether I choose to renew when it comes time to do so.  At this point, without demonstrative action by ICHCC to support its IARP certificants, including the timely advance approval of CEU's for IARP conferences as has always occurred in the past, I see no reason to continue holding the CLCP or attending IARP conferences if CEU's can't be confirmed in advance of conference registration.  The "solution" of offering CLCP CEU's after a conference is unacceptable to me as it requires a great leap of faith that I do not have.  What if ICHCC refuses to approve an IARP conference program after it has occurred?  If an IARP member then chose to not attend a conference because of this unresolved CEU issue, IARP can be damaged.  I believe the ICHCC needs to take steps to resolve the problem with IARP that seems be of its own creation.

    The bottom line to me is the ICHCC needs to stop (potentially) harming its (IARP member) certificants when it comes to approving IARP conference CEU's in advance of a conference  as it always has.  I urge IARP to take whatever steps it can to assure that this conflict is resolved regardless of the cost.

    Bob

    Robert H. Taylor
    1987 Haven's End
    Prescott, AZ 86305-2148
    (928)713-6833
    (720) 600-2636

    2162 Summerlin Ln
    Longmont, CO 80503
    (928) 713-6833 
    (720) 600-2636

    CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email, and any attachments, are confidential and may contain privileged or copyright information. If you are not the intended recipient you must not copy, distribute or use this email, or the information contained herein. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately, and delete this email and all attachments from your system. Thank you. Please consider the environment before printing this email.






  • 9.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-22-2022 14:38

    Good afternoon,

    I want to thank Tracy for opening this conversation.  I agree with PattyC, it IS possible to for professionals to address differences and reach resolution. 

    As with Patty, many were unaware of the CE issue until the Summit.  I too am confused as to why the Summit (and potentially the symposium and conference) was not eligible at the time of CE application but would be eligible later?  Why after decades of approval did it no longer meet the criteria?  We are discussing the quality and content of the presentations, not personal issues between organizations.

    We are looking to two professional organizations entrusted with advancing our professional growth and the credibility of the CLCP. I am painfully aware that things change, but sometimes we need to remember from where we came.  Years of hard work, time, and research have contributed to the advancement of life care planning and the credential we know today. That came with hard work and collaboration between the AANLCP (American Academy of Nurse Life Care Planners, later becoming transdisciplinary as the IALCP) and the ICHCC (then CDEC) and others, dating back to 1996-97. Since then life care planners have contributed time and money to seeking accreditation for the CLCP. 

    Only with transparency from our organizations will we eliminate the ongoing speculation and inaccurate information.  The inclusion of the life care planning practitioners and holders of the CLCP must to be involved in formulating a plan for resolution.

    I too am happy to participate on a task force or contribute however necessary to resolve this apparent impasse. It is difficult to assist with the solution when we do not know the problem.

    Let us remember our practice, and the credibility of the CLCP ultimately impacts what should be our priority, the people we serve. 

    All the best,

    Debbe



    ------------------------------
    Debbe Marcinko, FLCPRR President
    Life Care Planner, Case Manager
    debbem54@gmail.com
    Pittsburgh, PA United States
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-22-2022 18:53
    Tracy and Colleagues,

    I am the new chair of the IALCP Board and have not yet had the opportunity to introduce myself fully. At this time, however, I am writing on behalf of the IALCP Board.

    First, please know the IALCP is, and always has been, the umbrella organization for all life care planners. As we all know, life care planning is a transdisciplinary and diverse practice, with many different professions and certificate holders practicing in this arena. Our role is to be a "uniter" and not a "divider".

    We look forward to participating in resolving any issues among the groups.

    I acknowledge the request for transparency and provide the following:

    -CEU requests are submitted to all certifying organizations in advance of educational events. This includes CRC, CLCP, CDMS, CCM, CNLCP, and ABVE among others.

    -These certifying bodies have pre-approved CEUs for IALCP programs in the past.

    -Members in this community and on this Board dedicate and volunteer significant time and energy to organize and prepare for Summits, Symposiums and educational events. We seek quality speakers to provide information for our members to stay up to date and abreast of current issues and changes in the specialty practice of life care planning. We have again done this for the upcoming Symposium.

    -The IALCP Board firmly believes that any personal issues should have no bearing on pre-approval of CEUs. We will again be submitting CEU requests for the upcoming Symposium and future educational events to all certifying organizations.

    -Should a certifying organization not pre-approve credits, we will ask for insight and take steps within our power and ability to resolve any issues related to the quality and content of the proposed presentations, as we have done in the past. We have and will continue to work hard to obtain quality speakers at educational events for members.

    -We encourage certificate holders of any organization that has denied pre-approved CEUs to request further explanation from the denying organization directly.

    The IALCP will continue to work hard as the umbrella organization for all life care planners. This is a wonderful community, full of great members and volunteers who are highly dedicated to our specialty practice of life care planning. We encourage everyone to attend the upcoming Symposium and Conference. Please see the link to the upcoming Symposium schedule at https://rehabpro.org/page/conference-schedule for more information about the content being provided.

    We look forward to continuing these efforts for members. Please do not hesitate to ask further questions of the IALCP Board. Our goal is to be transparent and assist in any way we can moving the specialty practice of Life Care Planning into the future.

    Thank you,

    On behalf of the IALCP Board:

    -Nick Choppa, Chair
    -Susan Riddick-Grisham, Past Chair
    -Elizabeth Zaras, Chair-Elect
    -Laura Woodard – Representative to IARP Board of Directors
    -Sarah Malloy – Member at Large
    -Brook Feerick – Member at Large
    -Paul Ramos – Member at Large
    -Tricia Morrison – International Liaison to IALCP Board

    ------------------------------
    Nick Choppa
    Rehabilitation Counselor/Case Manager/Life Care Pl
    nick@osc-voc.com
    Seattle, WA United States
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-23-2022 10:51

    Thank you very much Nick for the update and the sharing of the Board's goals.

     

    Tracy Albee, RN LNCC CLCP FIALCP

    MediLegal, A Professional Nursing Corp

    1852 West 11th Street, #333

    Tracy, CA  95376

    209-833-7251

    tracy@medilegalinc.com

     

    Offices in Tracy, CA and Las Vegas, NV

     

    2023 Vacation Alert: I will be away from approximately June 5 thorugh July 5, 2023 and will be be unable to take accept new work with trials on calendar during that timeframe.

     

    The information contained in this message may be privileged, confidential and protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify your representative immediately and delete this message from your computer. Thank you.

     






  • 12.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-23-2022 18:39
    The note is very helpful as all of this gets sorted out - I would encourage members not to forget that IARP has an exceptional credential that is worth pursuing.

    ------------------------------
    Rebecca Busch
    CEO
    rebecca@mbaaudit.com
    Westmont, IL United States
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: Issues between IARP and ICHCC

    Posted 08-24-2022 13:11
    just in case - since i was asked a question regarding my post    https://connect.rehabpro.org/lcp/fellow/fellow-program    this is the link to find out about the credential.

    ------------------------------
    Rebecca Busch
    CEO
    rebecca@mbaaudit.com
    Westmont, IL United States
    ------------------------------